Scott Derrickson returns with The Black Phone 2, a chilling follow-up to his 2022 supernatural hit — and critics agree it’s one of the boldest horror sequels of the year. Released on October 17, 2025, the film has already earned an impressive 82% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, proving that the haunting world of the Grabber still has plenty to offer.
A Bigger, Bolder Nightmare
While the first Black Phone was an intimate, claustrophobic story set largely in a basement, the sequel broadens its scope — taking the terror to a remote, snow-covered camp where new horrors unfold. The visual style is striking, blending Super 8-inspired sequences and eerie dreamscapes that channel classic horror vibes reminiscent of A Nightmare on Elm Street.
Ethan Hawke once again delivers a masterful performance as the menacing Grabber, earning praise for his chilling intensity. The sequel dives deeper into his twisted psyche while introducing new characters that expand the mythology established in the first film.
A Shift in Tone
Critics have noted that The Black Phone 2 trades some of the original’s tightly wound suspense for spectacle and scale. Some reviewers described the film as “ambitious but messy,” pointing out that its expanded world sometimes dilutes the intimate terror that made the first movie so effective.
However, others praised Derrickson’s willingness to evolve the franchise rather than rehash it. The film’s darker tone, richer visuals, and supernatural elements have been widely commended for delivering a fresh yet familiar dose of dread.
Critical Response
According to GamesRadar+, the film is “a tremendous, nightmarish sequel that surpasses expectations.” Bloody Disgusting called it “bigger, darker, and scarier — a haunting descent into fear.” Meanwhile, Tom’s Guide praised its visual storytelling, noting that its vintage look “adds layers of unease that keep the audience glued to their seats.”
Still, some critics, such as KSL.com, found the story “overly convoluted,” arguing that its expanded mythology comes at the expense of emotional resonance.
The Final Verdict
The Black Phone 2 succeeds as a stylish, atmospheric continuation of the original — even if it occasionally stumbles under the weight of its own ambition. It’s a film that honors its roots while daring to grow beyond them, offering a different kind of fear: broader, colder, and perhaps even more haunting.
Fans of the first movie will find familiar chills, but those craving something new in the horror genre will appreciate Derrickson’s willingness to take risks.
Verdict: ★★★★☆ (4/5) — A haunting sequel that dares to dream bigger, even if it sometimes bites off more than it can scream.
Sources:
GamesRadar – “The Black Phone 2” Called ‘Tremendous, Nightmarish, and Better Than the Original’
0 Comments